But omg when everyone started turning to dust the whole theater lost their shit. I screamed when wanda turned to dust like holy shit. AND THEN SPIDEY I DONT WANT TO GO MR STARK WAS SO HEARTBREAKING LIKE THIS MOVIE Ahhhhhhhh

Mine was silent both times, like it was a funeral. Spidey’s death was the only one that made me cry on my first watch. When Vision was being killed I was doing mental floor routines trying to figure out how he could get out of this, how he didn’t really have to die, so I wasn’t fully in the moment. And boy, Thanos sure showed me how Vision could get out of that…

Just curious do you think Vision is really dead? I hope not.

@huntressride 
Do you think vision is really going to stay dead? My heart is exploding at the thought of Wanda living without him!

I am so biased here! I really am. I can’t get a good sense of where the narrative might go because I’m hung up on what I want to happen. Not to mention IW ends in such a dramatically upending way it’s hard to know what the next step. So do I think he will live? I say he can live.

They have to be incredibly conscious of how bringing back dead characters will cheapen loss for any truly dead character and lower the stakes of the movie. So if they decide to do it, they have to fulfill certain criteria to make it satisfying. There must be preceding justification, it must fulfill a need for the story that could not have been fulfilled otherwise, the audience must be made to feel as strongly (in a positive way) about bringing him back as they felt when he died.

For Vision, we have two routes. The first is Shuri has a backup copy. I’d even point out this bit in the Infinity War prelude comic:

image

Shuri was able to digitally copy Bucky’s brain and then basically overwrite him with that copy. She did that with a living, organic being. Hell yeah she could do that with Vision.

There’s also the notion that Vision’s consciousness might reside in the Mind Stone, which I argued for here.

Though I would like to point out these two things are not mutually exclusive.

As far as story concerns, there’s plenty of ways it could go that would make Vision returning critical. You have to think about the things that are unique to Vision and perhaps unique to the way he died: he bore the Mind Stone; Wanda is in love with him; his death was reversed (natural order, as Wong would say); Wanda sacrificed what she loved most, etc. So long as it plays off of those things, it’s viable.

The last is the trickiest. I’ve said it before, but there was so much emphasis placed on his death, it does make it feel very permanent. They would have to place quite a bit of emphasis on what it means for him to come back to make up for it.

What I suspect–or perhaps I should say the most I hope for–is that Vision is not directly resurrected, but rather his consciousness comes to the fore in the Mind Stone, and Wanda perhaps has a scene (like Thanos and Gamora) with him before he’s gone for good. I don’t think the movie will fully resurrect him, but I think it will provide Wanda with closure, especially if they hope to use her in the future.

I seriously don’t know how to recover from Vision’s deaths and ScarletVision and Avengers IW in general. I mean, his last words and scenes haunted me despite knowing that he’s just a fictional character. I’ve seen a lot of his developments in IW and I was blown away but his ending was so horrible. I need more than a hug :((

It’s okay, IW’s ending was just one of the timelines Strange saw. In the real timeline, Wanda said yes to staying with Vision and they decided to travel the world! The Northern Cascades were their first stop.

image

They can spend awhile there, since Vision only carries provisions for Wanda. Wanda likes the mountains–they remind her of Sokovia. Vision likes that it’s mostly wilderness, so he doesn’t have to worry as much about staying in disguise. Wanda has perfected a low-level telekinetic field that acts as a mosquito repellent. Vision, on the other hand, gets excited when a bug lands on him. He is particularly fond of northern bluets.

Infinity war literally destroyed my heart oh my goddddddd

I just got back from watching it again! Oh my god, it’s even more emotional the second time. The preparation only breaks your heart more. I noticed some new things!

  • When Wanda hops Vision and her up to the roof, Vision pushes her away last second as Proxima comes in and takes the hit.
  • Vision loves kissing her hands. I think he does it at least once in every major scene they’re in.
  • When Wanda’s expression changes after Vision asks if they can stay together, Vision responds ‘Or not, if I’m overstepping myself…’ This is such a sweet development for him! He recognizes the nuances of Wanda’s feelings now, and he accommodates them. Vision was never trying to control Wanda.
  • You know how the late Englehart Vision got almost shockingly human to show how he’s grown as a person? I love how the MCU variant of this is him being a stuttery, enthusiastic nerd when it comes to Wanda.
  • Adding to the Thanos and Wanda parallels, Gamora’s last words (and last words to Thanos) are: “This isn’t love”. Vision’s are “I love you”.
  • I missed how often and how sadly Cap looked at Vision and Wanda together. He really felt for them!
  • I’m curious what the scenario is of Vision’s “stolen moments” with Wanda. Tony says Vision turned off his transponder two weeks ago–he says it like it’s an abnormal occurrence and he definitely doesn’t know where Vision is. So Vision doing so isn’t normal. Does this mean he was planning so early to ask to stay with Wanda?
  • As the Mind Stone starts to break, one of the first cracks that forms on his face runs down from his eye like a tear.

Why is there so much Wanda hate? Honestly curious. I don’t get it. (Also, Vision hate)

If you mean for IW, I haven’t seen hate yet. Perhaps some people are bitter about Wanda not killing Vision earlier, but whether she would or not made no difference because all the heroes were in agreement that nobody should have to kill Vision, and they’d rather fight. Not to mention, once Thanos got the Time Stone, it didn’t matter when she did it.

If you mean from before, there are two camps:

  1. People who are angry at how the character was adapted. She is Romani in the comics, and Marvel cast a non-Romani woman, and had her working with HYDRA. This is a subject I’m not going to get into it this moment.
  2. People who are angry that Wanda messed with Tony and Tony gets full blame for Ultron but Wanda doesn’t.

For the record, I agree Wanda is also responsible for Ultron, it’s just not as important to her character arc anymore, because it’s her origin story. She was narratively punished by the death of her brother and the destruction of the home she was trying to save. It’s the final piece in her becoming an Avenger. That’s why no one keeps going back to it. For Tony, though, it’s a part of an ongoing character development.

As for Vision, that’s mostly people who don’t like his relationship with Wanda for the most part. That is about two things usually:

  1. The idea Vision was manipulating Wanda in CW, which I addressed here
  2. The age difference between the actors, which I addressed here

I really love your theory that Vision’s consciousness has survived within the Mind Stone and will fight Thanos from there. Just like Gamora is somehow inside the Soul Stone. But I also wonder if Shuri managed to separate his consciousness from the Mind Stone before she was interrupted and she, Bruce and Tony will reanimate him in A4. She did take the file with her when she escaped the lab.

Oh, I didn’t catch that! I’ll be seeing the movie again today, so I’ll be able to soak in details a bit better. That’s fascinating. So, with only part of Vision’s brain–the parts that canonically make up the less-sentient, less advanced side of him–and with a colorless Vision corpse lying around, and a super genius who’s the world’s expert on vibranium right nearby as well as one of his original creators…

image

I really hope Vision comes back. I mean the movie really goes to some dark places but at the end it’s still a Marvel/Disney movie. Would they be really that cruel to Wanda? Plus they went to all that effort to sell their relationship but it ends in tragedy? I don’t know. I hope not. Their comic relationship is sad enough.

I mean, I don’t think it gets much more dark in a Marvel/Disney movie that having our hero kill the man she loves only to watch him get resurrected and have half his head ripped out and then for her to die too.

We saw him die, twice. Both deaths were very drawn out, and in fact the most drawn out in a movie filled to the brim with deaths. Even some of the more standalone ones, like Loki and Gamora’s were not treated the same way. And then to get the imagine of the Stone ripped out, and his lifeless body falling to the ground? That’s really selling the death.

And then there’s the fact there seemed to be somewhat of a divide between characters who got a decent amount of screentime, lines, relationship developments, and characters who did not. And, notably, most of the characters who did not are the characters who got dusted. Implying, to me, they’re going to shine in A4. But Vision, especially compared to Wanda, had some pretty substantial moments.

Honestly, at this point, I’m guessing Vision stays dead, and Wanda gets a substantial role in the next film. But we’ll see.

Is Wanda’s plot going to be all around Vision? Did not she have a brother who died? Why MCU forgot her brother ??

I talked about that a bit here, too.

I assume it’s also going to about her realizing her powers and what that means for her as a person. That’s what the Russos have said her journey is about. So far her footage frames her in a protective role, she has a plenty good reason to develop and expand her powers.

As far as Pietro–that story wrapped up with Ultron. His death was the final piece of Wanda’s narrative redemption. Besides Marvel Studios not wanting to deal with two Quicksilvers, Wanda’s character and relationships would be difficult to develop if he were still alive. Wanda had only 10 minutes of screentime (including non-speaking) in CW–a sizable chunk of that would have gone with Pietro, and that’s not the story they wanted to tell.

This is true of the comics too. To my recollection, Wanda and Pietro haven’t been on an ongoing together since a little after their Kooky Quartet days. They’ve had story arcs together, but not as ongoing teammates.

And as far as an in-universe reason goes:

  1. By Infinity War it’s been 3-4 years.
  2. People won’t talk about their dead loved ones to others who didn’t know them, and the Avengers didn’t really.
  3. Again, Wanda doesn’t have that much screentime. Not a lot of space for her to bring up her dead brother.

Pietro may end up featuring in Wanda’s story in some capacity. But it wouldn’t be surprising to me at all if he won’t, and it would be a screenwriting mistake to bring him up beyond a short, meaningful mention unless they plan on it.